Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment
The Normative Approach

Knowledge Center

   

The Normative Approach. Explanation of Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment of Berman, Wicks, Kotha, Jones and Freeman.

Contents

  1. Summary
  2. Forum
  3. Best Practices
  4. Expert Tips
  5. Resources
  6. Print

The Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment is described by Berman, Wicks, Kotha, Jones (Academy of Management Journal; Oct99, Vol. 42 Issue 5). They use earlier work of Edward Freeman about the Normative Approach.


What is Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment? Definition

This model is called the intrinsic or normative stakeholder commitment model because the interests of stakeholders have intrinsic value. These interests enter a firm's decision making prior to strategic considerations, and they form a moral foundation for corporate strategy itself.


Normative approaches towards stakeholder theory hold that:


Managers ought to pay attention to key stakeholder relationships.


According to this perspective, managerial relationships with stakeholders are based on normative, moral commitments. Rather than on a desire to use those stakeholders solely to maximize profits. In short, a firm establishes certain fundamental moral principles. These guide how the company does business, in particular with respect to how it treats stakeholders. And the corporation uses those principles as a basis for decision-making.

intrinsic stakeholder commitment normative approachOne genesis of this normative model is the fact that company decisions affect stakeholder outcomes. Ethics, generally speaking, deals with obligations that arise when an individual or corporate agent's decisions affect others; regardless of precisely what constitutes an ethical decision, decisions made without any consideration of their impact on others are usually thought to be unethical. Donaldson and Preston (1995) captured the implications of this view for stakeholder management well by stating that the stakeholder interests have intrinsic worth. That is, certain claims of stakeholders are based on fundamental moral principles. They are unrelated to the instrumental value of the stakeholders for a corporation. A firm cannot ignore or cannot abridge these claims, simply because honoring them does not serve its strategic interests, or is strategically inconvenient. In a sense, these claims are independent of, and should be addressed prior to, corporate strategic considerations. Stakeholder interests are thought to form the foundation of Corporate Strategy itself. They represent what we are as a company, and what we think is important.

Given such a stakeholder orientation, a firm shapes its strategy around certain moral obligations to its stakeholders. In this vein, a Kantian posture (Bowie, 1994; Evan & Freeman, 1983), a feminist perspective (Wicks, Gilbert, & Freeman, 1994), and a fair contracts approach (Freeman, 1994; Phillips, 1997) are examples of moral principles that can form the normative foundation for stakeholder-oriented management. Freeman and Gilbert explicated this perspective:

We cannot connect ethics and strategy. Unless there is a point of intersection between the values and ethics we hold, and the business practices that exemplify these values and ethics. To build strategy on ethics and to avoid a process that looks much like post hoc rationalization of what we actually did, we need to ask :"what do we stand for?" in conjunction with our strategic decisions. (1988)

The second genesis of a normative stakeholder orientation based on moral principles is the argument that making a strategic commitment to morality is not only conceptually flawed but is also ineffective. To strategically apply ethical principles means that a firm only acts according to moral principles when this is to its advantage. However this is by definition not following ethical principles at all. In addition, Quinn and Jones (1995) argued that if the purpose of acting ethically is to acquire a good reputation that, in turn, will provide a firm with economic benefits, why not pursue the good reputation directly without the intellectual excursion into moral philosophy? In some cases, of course, the behavior called for will coincide with that dictated by ethics, but in others it may not. What difference does ethics make if one can act instrumentally without reference to ethics?

From a practical perspective, Jones (1995) argued that the instrumental benefits of stakeholder management paradoxically result only from a genuine commitment to ethical principles. He argued that firms which create, and sustain, stakeholder relationships based on mutual trust and cooperation will have a competitive advantage over other firms that do not act in this way (cf. Barney & Hansen, 1994). If a firm's commitment to trust and cooperation is strategic rather than intrinsic, it will be difficult for the firm to maintain the sincere manner and reputation (Frank, 1988) required for its differential desirability as an economic partner. In other words, trustworthiness, honesty, and integrity are difficult to fake. Thus, to reap the instrumental benefits of stakeholder management, a firm must be committed to ethical relationships with stakeholders. Regardless of the expected benefits. Strategically applied moral commitments are not really moral. And, paradoxically, they cannot cause the desired strategic outcomes.


Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment | Normative Approach Forum
  Stakeholders in Mine Project Development
Indigenous community owners of surface lands are no longer passive participants of the mining businesses. At the contrary, nowadays they have become very active stakeholders with a veto right on the project development. Even more than central governm...
     
 
  Business Ethics and Stakeholder Management
Stakeholders' Intrinsic Value Perspective implies that as a manager you should never harm stakeholders in a non-ethical way. For example you should not take advantage of your employees, you should not cheat on your customers and business partn...
     
 
  What Kind of Values Should Have the Code of Ethics?
I think is neccesary define which values should have the stakeholders, because if the most of them have the economic aspect at their first and the only interest then I think wil be very dificut to obtain an advance in this topic, I suggest that thi...
     
 
  External and Internal Forces
How do the external change forces influence the organisation?...
     
 
  Adopting the Code of Ethics
What are the motivations for adopting the code of ethics using the normative form and using the instrumental form of stakeholder theory?...
     
 
  What is Normative Management?
What does normative management mean?...
     
 

Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment | Normative Approach Special Interest Group


Special Interest Group

Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment | Normative Approach Education & Events


Find Trainings, Seminars and Events


Best Practices - Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment | Normative Approach Premium
  Building Trust in your Firm
One clear advantage of deploying an intrinsic stakeholder commitment philosophy is that it it is very strong in building trust between the business and the stakeholders / civic society as a whole. Because the firm is inherently interested in building...
     
 

Expert Tips - Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment | Normative Approach Premium
 

Stakeholder Capitalism (Freeman)

Professor Freeman has recently published a formidable article about this subject in the Journal of Business Ethics (2007-74:303-314). In his article c...
Usage (application): Stakeholder Management
 
 
 

How to Effectively Conduct a Stakeholders Meeting?

Here are a few tips to effectively manage a stakeholders meeting:
1. Try to avoid getting into details and drawn into a conversation about a lo...
Usage (application): Stakeholder Meetings, Best Practices
 
 
 

The Maturity Stages of Corporate Responsibility

Simon Zadek provides a useful best practice five-stage maturity model of how organizations deal with Corporate Responsibility:
- Defensive: deny ...
Usage (application): Organizational Development, Corporate Responsibility Maturity
 
 

Resources - Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment | Normative Approach Premium

The Purpose of Business: Stockholder versus Stakeholder Theories

This presentation elaborates on the objectives and purposes of businesses according to different views: those of stockholders and those of stakeholder...
Usage (application): Stakeholder Analysis; Stakeholder Commitment
 

Change of Governance in Historic Perspective: The German Experience

Various threads of the insider-controlled and stakeholder-oriented governance system in Germany have started to unravel, and certain elements typicall...
Usage (application): German Experience
 

Exceptional Speech by then 13 year-old Severn Suzuki at the UN, 2008 on Environmental and Social Responsibility

At the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development 2008, a 13 years old child, speaking for ECO, the Environmental Children's Organizatio...
Usage (application): Environmental Responsibility, Social Responsibility
 

Stakeholder versus Shareholder Satisfaction in Corporate Risk Management

Inherent in corporate governance is the conflict between satisfying stakeholders in general versus satisfying shareholders in particular. This empiric...
Usage (application): Corporate Risk Management
 

The Dawn of Conscious Capitalism

This presentation provides an introduction into the concept of conscious capitalism, and includes the following sections:
1. Introduction
2....
Usage (application): Conscious Capitalism, Value-driven Consumer, Socially Responsible Investing, Corporate Responsibility
 

CSR Implementation and Communication Model (Schmeltz)

Because Corporate Social Responsibility is a value-based concept, it is highly connected with an organizationís values and corporate identity. Actuall...
Usage (application): CSR Communication, CSR Implementation, CSR Strategy, Corporate Identity, Corporate Values, CSR Stages,
 

Fundamentals of Business Ethics

Presentation about business ethics, including an explanation of its relation with economics and the law. It also includes three important ethical mana...
Usage (application): Business Ethics, Corporate Ethics, Ethical Behavior, Corporate Responsibility, Stakeholder Management
 

Stakeholder Theory and Corporate Governance: The Role of Intangible Assets

This paper by Arturo Capasso, building on the resource based view of the firm, but also on stakeholder approach to strategic management, explores how ...
Usage (application): Stakeholder Theory, Governance
 

Stephen Covey on the Speed of Trust

Steven Covey hints at some of the reasons why trust is so fundamental for corporations, the banking system, financial institutions and the global econ...
Usage (application): Corporate Strategy, Global Economy, Banking System, Leadership Development, Stakeholder Management
 

Introduction to Stakeholder Management

David Butter explains what stakeholders are and their importance for organizations, distinguishing internal from external stakeholders....
Usage (application): Introduction to Stakeholder Management
 

Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment Diagram

Download and edit this 12manage PowerPoint graphic for limited personal, educational and business use. Republishing in intranets, websites, books, ma...
Usage (application): Stakeholder Management
 
 

News

Intrinsic Stakeholders
     
 

News

Normative Stakeholders
     
 

Videos

Intrinsic Stakeholders
     
 

Videos

Normative Stakeholders
     
 

Presentations

Intrinsic Stakeholders
     
 

Presentations

Normative Stakeholders
     
 

More

Intrinsic Stakeholders
     
 

More

Normative Stakeholders
     

Compare with Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment: Strategic Stakeholder Management  |  Seven Signs Of Ethical Collapse  |  Moral Purpose  |  Value Based Management  |  Clarkson Principles  |  Strategic Intent  |  Shareholder Value Perspective  |  Stakeholder Value Perspective  |  Stakeholder Analysis  |  Stakeholder Mapping


Return to Management Hub: Ethics & Responsibility  |  Human Resources  |   Leadership  |  Strategy


More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Special Interest Group Leader

You here


About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us | Privacy | Terms of Service
Copyright 2016 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V14.0 - Last updated: 30-8-2016. All names tm by their owners.