Bridging Epistemologies
(Cook Brown)

Knowledge Center

   

The generative dance towards knowledge creation that bridges the epistemologies of possession and action. Explanation of Bridging Epistemologies of Cook and Brown. ('99)

Contributed by: Tom de Geytere

Contents

  1. Summary
  2. Forum
  3. Expert Tips
  4. Resources

Print

Bridging Epistemologies

Knowledge Center

Why register?

Cook Brown Bridging Epistemologies model

What is the Bridging Epistemologies framework? Description

S.D.N. Cook and J.S. Brown argue that much current work on organizational knowledge, intellectual capital, knowledge-creating organizations, knowledge work and the like is based on a single, traditional understanding of the nature of knowledge. In this "epistemology of possession," knowledge is treated like something which people possess. Yet, this vision can not account for the knowing which is found in individual and group practice.


Knowing as action calls for an "epistemology of practice." Moreover, the epistemology of possession tends to privilege explicit over tacit knowledge. Also it tends to privilege individual knowledge over group knowledge.

Current work on organizations is limited by this privileging, and by the scant attention given to knowing. Organizations are better understood if explicit, tacit, individual and group knowledge are treated as four distinct and coequal forms of knowledge. Each is doing work the others can't. Knowledge and knowing should be seen like mutually enabling; not like competing.


Actions by collectives cannot be reduced to only the actions of individuals within them. Cook and Brown identify 4 types of knowledge: explicit and tacit at the individual and collective levels, and consider how they are bridged by the active process of knowing (OUBS,2001). The process by which different knowledge types are used in practice is described as a "generative dance". According to this metaphor, knowledge creation does not simply rely on an inventory of knowledge elements (possession), but on the ability to use those as tools (action).


Cook and Brown hold that knowledge is a tool of knowing, that knowing is an aspect of our interaction with the social and physical world, and that the interplay of knowledge and knowing can generate new knowledge and new ways of knowing.


Origin of the Bridging Epistemologies model. History

The model from Cook and Brown developed from:

  • Polanyi's distinction between tacit and explicit knowledge (1983). Tacit knowledge is what is not easily visible and expressible. Tacit knowledge is personal, context specific and hard to formalize and communicate. Subjective insights, intuitions and hunches fall in this category, which includes cognitive and technical elements. Explicit knowledge can be expressed in words and numbers and can be easily communicated and shared in the form of hard data, scientific formulae, codified procedures and universal principles. (Nonaka and Takeuchi).
  • Spender's epistemological pluralism (1998): (1) objective knowledge is only one way of knowing things, and (2) some aspects of explicit and tacit knowledge are only known collectively (see also Blackler, 1995).

It adds a dynamic element of knowledge and opposes the traditional knowledge-as-assets or resource view of knowledge. This model resembles the view of Nonaka and Takeuchi in their SECI model, which sees knowledge creation as a transformation of the various knowledge elements.
 

Usage of the Bridging Epistemologies framework. Applications

The framework Cook and Brown helps to think of knowledge in an organizational context and understanding why and how we know things collectively. Their model strengthens the link between product and process innovation. In their view, forms of knowledge distributed among individuals and groups are not the only essential for product development; ways of "knowing" reflected in the interaction of the workers with each other and their objects of work are also essential (OUBS,2001).


An example of the Bridging Epistemologies model

The model is illustrated using the simple example of a bakery: Relevant tools are:

  • Knowledge as concepts. Theory known by individuals, like which flour to use, how much salt to use etc.
  • Skills. The ability to make bread
  • Stories. How things were built up
  • Genre. The context of the bakery

An apprentice can learn or be part of all these elements, he or she will need experience in order to make bread: knowledge as action.


Assumptions of the Bridging Epistemologies model. Conditions

  • Knowledge can not be transformed from its various forms (individual/tacit etc.), but exist in distinct forms.

Article: Cook and Brown - Bridging Epistemologies.




Bridging Epistemologies Forum (2 topics) Help
To get access to this forum, you need to be a member: Register
  Tacit Knowledge and Experience Transfer
A large part of a person´s unique expertise is by nature, tacit. Tacit knowledge is also known as personal knowledge, which gradually has become a part of the skilled worker. These qualities are rarely easy to define or explain in words, whether verb...
     
  Communicating Bridging Epistemologies to Superiors
This information is very insightful and should be used in everyday life. We all should find a way to communicate this to our superiors without being insubordinate. I know I am!...
     
Start a new discussion: Register
Bridging Epistemologies Special Interest Group


Special Interest Group

Bridging Epistemologies Education & Events


Find Trainings, Seminars and Events


Expert Tips - Bridging Epistemologies Premium
Discover and utilize expert tips per method: Register
 

Barriers that Hinder Effective Knowledge Sharing

According to Chris Collison, there are seven common barriers or syndromes that hinder effecti...
Usage (application): Effective Knowledge Sharing, Pitfalls to Avoid, Knowledge Management Implementation
 
 

Positive Effects of Age Diversity on Company Productivity and (Tacit) Knowledge Sharing

Backes-Gellner and Veen (2013) outlined the main advantages of having a diverse workforce within a company. The following positive effects were pointe...
Usage (application): Tacit Knowledge Transfer, Workforce Productivity, Incentive Management
 
 

How to Identify and Map Knowledge

In his article “Knowledge Mapping: The Essentials for Success”, Wesley Vestal provides following six tips to identify and map knowledge:
1. Defin...
Usage (application): Knowledge Identification, Knowledge Capturing, Knowledge Storage
 
 

Critical Activities to Build a Learning Organization

Learning organizations are distinguished because they are undertaking certain activities to foster the internal learning process. Those activities inc...
Usage (application): Implementing Organizational Learning, Best Practices
 
 

Capturing Learned Lessons

Knowledge from bad and good experiences will lead you and your organization to better future performance. You can improve your learning culture with <...
Usage (application): How to Capture Organizational Learning? Best Practices
 
 

How Culture Levels Explain Failures in Organizational Learning and Innovation

Schein (as cited by Bertagni et al., 2010) tries to elaborate on the question why organizational innovations often fail or are only successful in the ...
Usage (application): Improving Organizational Learning, Organizational Innovation, Changing Organization Cultures
 
 

Knowledge Management Scope

Research by Deishin Lee (HBS) and Eric Van den Steen (MIT) shows that recording mediocre know-how can actually be counter-productive, since such medio...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Level of Know-how
 
 

Components of Learning Agility

One of the critical factors for achieving organizational agility is learning agility, which refers to the ability and eagerness to learn from experien...
Usage (application): Organizational Agility, Organizational Learning, Knowledge Management
 
 

Knowledge Management Focal Point

Research by Deishin Lee (HBS) and Eric Van den Steen (MIT) shows that information about successes is typically more useful than information about fail...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management Focus
 

Resources - Bridging Epistemologies Premium
Access presentations, news and videos on each method: Register

How to Improve Knowledge Sharing in Knowledge-intensive Organizations

This presentation elaborates on the concept of knowledge sharing, thereby focusin on a knowledge-intensive organization context. The presentation incl...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Sharing Motivation, Knowledge Sharing Platform. Tacit Knowledge

Overview of Existing Types of Knowledge

This presentation provides an overview of the different types of knowledge that exist. The presentation includes the following sections:
1. Knowl...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Types, Tacit, Implicit, Explicit, Declarative, Procedural Knowledge

Knowledge Management Systems Architecture

This presentation is about knowledge development and management, including the following sections:
1. Overview
2. Knowledge creation
3....
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Creation, Knowledge Systems, Knowledge Architecture

Introduction to Knowledge Management: Foundation Principles and Building Concepts

1. What is Knowledge?
1. What is Knowledge Management? Definition
2. Knowledge Foundation Principles and Building Concepts
2.1. Knowled...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Sharing, Learning Organization

Three Levels of Knowledge Management

According to Jury (2007), knowledge management can be categorized into three different levels, and organized in a pyramid form, in which the highest l...
Usage (application): Initial Understanding Knowledge Management, Organizational Learning

Knowledge Sharing and Organizational Learning through Communities of Practices

Knowledge management in Communities of Practice (CoPs)
This presentation is about organizational learning and knowledge sharing, thereby emphasiz...
Usage (application): Knowledge Sharing, Organizational Learning, Communities of Practices, Special Interest Groups

Knowledge Creation: The SECI Model

Presentation about the SECI model of Nonaka and Takeuchi (1996), a model about knowledge creation. The model is...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Creation

Knowledge Transfer and Knowledge Sharing

Preentation that is an introduction into the concept of Knowledge Transfer, including its fundamentals, strategies, guidelines and roles. The presenta...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Sharing, Knowledge Transfer

Professor Evans Explains Why Fast Change Requires New Ways of Learning and Thinking

In this historic video Action Learning Professor Reg Evans shows that it is very important to understand that today's rate of change (C) is exponentia...
Usage (application): Action Learning, Coping with Change, The Need of Change, The Need for New Ways of Learning

Knowledge Transfer in the E-world

This is a presentation about Knowledge Transfer (KT), specifically focused on KT in the e-world. The presentation consists of the following sections:<...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management, Knowledge Transfer, Internet, Intranet, E-Business, CRM

Bridging Epistemologies Diagram

Download and edit this 12manage PowerPoint graphic for limited personal, educational and business use. Republishing in intranets, websites, books, ma...
Usage (application): Knowledge Management
 

News

Bridging Epistemologies
     
 

News

Knowledge Organization
     
 

Videos

Bridging Epistemologies
     
 

Videos

Knowledge Organization
     
 

Presentations

Bridging Epistemologies
     
 

Presentations

Knowledge Organization
     
 

More

Bridging Epistemologies
     
 

More

Knowledge Organization
     

Compare with Bridging Epistemologies: SECI model  |  Organizational Learning  |  Organizational Memory  |  Action Learning  |  Knowledge Management (Collison & Parcell)


Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |  Human Resources  |  Knowledge & Intangibles


More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Sponsor
Sponsor this knowledge center

Special Interest Group Leader
Expert? Become our Bridging Epistemologies SIG Leader.

All you need to know about management

12manage for:












































Copyright 2016 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V14.0 - Last updated: 7-2-2016. All names tm by their owners.